Knit Me A Pony: Status Message Here

I tell stories.
~ Thursday, July 26 ~

Articles about “fake geek girls” provoke online backlash


Just a day after noted comics critic Gail Simone blogged her frustration with the misconception that girls don’t read comics, CNN posted a double serving of backlash against girls in geek culture on its GeekOut! blog, drawing perplexed responses from fans across the Internet.

The first article, “Camp Breaking Dawn’ and the ‘Twilight’ of the Boys’ Club,” noted that women had, especially since the ‘90s, become more active in geek culture. “Many of today’s best online comic and fantasy-genre news sites and discussion groups were started by, and remain powered by, women,” wrote author Rob Salkowitz.

Yet, Salkowitz then went on to imply that girls mostly only showed up at Comic-Con because of Twilight. “Girls don’t read comics,” opined one reader on Twitter in response, while other fans scratched their heads.

Twilight fans were at Doctor WhoGame of Thrones, TheFirefly Reunion, The Walking DeadTrue Blood, The Revolution Panel checking out the next project from two people in the Twilight cast, The Hobbit,” commenter Laurareplied to the original post. “There is this misconception thatTwilight fans like only Twilight. For most fans, it’s pure escapist fun, it’s just one aspect of what they enjoy.”


“That thing where dudes generously ‘bestow’ male privilege on women who like the right stuff the right way,” raanve added. “No thanks.”

Just a few hours after this article ruffled feathers, writer Joe Peacock sent flames across the Internet with his own GeekOut! article, “Booth Babes Need Not Apply.”

“I hate poachers. Pure and simple,” he said, speaking of the trend of so-called “booth babes” representing companies at cons—according to Peacock, these women are just “pretty girls pretending to be geeks for attention.”

It went downhill from there:

Read more at The Daily Dot!

69 notes
  1. peppers-pray reblogged this from bookshop
  2. soupytwists reblogged this from bookshop
  3. thegeekgirlwhatrules reblogged this from lovingmyselfishard
  4. meredithann reblogged this from peggolson and added:
    i’m tired of the misogyny of geek culture and how so many men involved with it believe that women are there as tools to...
  5. merinnan reblogged this from bookshop
  6. industryofvillains reblogged this from hellotailor
  7. thulite reblogged this from karykeion
  8. karykeion reblogged this from knitmeapony and added:
    You know, if he’d just said “Man, you know what sucks? People who look down on geek culture but capitalize on it anyway...
  9. bropunzeling reblogged this from hellotailor
  10. mikanrulz reblogged this from bookshop
  11. lizbethanne reblogged this from hellotailor
  12. marysueprincess reblogged this from thulite
  13. sailorsunspot reblogged this from willowaus
  14. willowaus reblogged this from northstarfan
  15. angrysquirrelsays reblogged this from hellotailor
  16. singitforthegirls reblogged this from hellotailor and added:
    … I must then not be a girl since I read comics on the bus to and from work today. And that wasn’t even the first time,...
  17. lady-writes reblogged this from bookshop
  18. lovingmyselfishard reblogged this from bookshop and added:
    The first problem is that anyone expected CNN to publish anything relevant. And second, I really hope this increased...
  19. raptureofthedance reblogged this from bookshop
  20. northstarfan reblogged this from knitmeapony
  21. knitmeapony reblogged this from bookshop
  22. spinwhirlpin reblogged this from peggolson
  23. missalimcd reblogged this from hellotailor and added:
    Geebus…a “pretty” gal can be as geeky a comic nerd as a anyone else who loves the medium of comics, sci fi, fantasy, and...
  24. feathersflight reblogged this from hellotailor
  25. nothingsgonebutnothingslasting reblogged this from peggolson
  26. badinfluencespeaks reblogged this from hellotailor
  27. plaguehands reblogged this from hellotailor
  28. peggolson reblogged this from bookshop
  29. hellotailor reblogged this from bookshop
  30. dazebras reblogged this from bookshop
reblogged via bookshop